4 Common Workflow Mistakes (And How To Fix Them)
That “Instant Unsubscribe” Moment
You’re excited to join a brand’s email list, expecting a steady stream of emails you’ll love, exclusive offers, or maybe a helpful welcome email series.
But instead, you get hit with three emails in one afternoon, or a random message that has nothing to do with why you signed up.
It’s the kind of experience that instantly makes you think, “Maybe I made a mistake.”
For anyone who manages emails (whether it’s a small business owner or a marketing team for a brand) avoiding this experience is important.
A mismanaged workflow not only frustrates readers, it risks losing subscribers who could have become loyal customers.
Running a regular email workflow audit can prevent that instant unsubscribe moment, keep your emails fresh, and make sure each workflow aligns with your audience’s needs and expectations.
What Is an Email Workflow?
Email workflows are automated series of emails sent based on specific subscriber actions, like joining your list, abandoning a cart, or not engaging with your emails for a while.
Rather than hitting “send” on every email individually, you create a journey that leads subscribers through valuable content or offers based on where they are in their journey with you.
Workflows help you build connections while saving you time. But if they’re not set up thoughtfully, they can easily misfire, leaving subscribers feeling more overwhelmed than looking forward to hearing from you.
Why Running an Email Workflow Audit Matters
A regular audit helps you catch small workflow hiccups before they cause bigger issues.
By reviewing open rates, checking on automated messages, and staying on top of content, you make sure each email serves its purpose and engages your readers.
When your workflows are intentional, they help create a streamlined experience that’s focused on building relationships rather than just filling inboxes.
Audits make sure each workflow still aligns with your brand and gives readers the kind of value they signed up for.
How Often Should You Audit Your Email Workflows?
A good rule of thumb is to do an audit at least twice a year, but if you’re in a fast-paced industry or if your audience’s needs change frequently, quarterly audits can be more effective.
Each audit is a chance to align your workflows with your evolving goals and see what’s working, what isn’t, and where a couple small tweaks can bring you better results.
4 Common Workflow Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)
1. Sending Too Many Emails Too Quickly
Nothing makes a subscriber scroll for the “unsubscribe” button faster than an email onslaught.
Sending multiple emails in a day (especially in a welcome sequence) can feel overwhelming and leave readers wondering why they subscribed in the first place.
How to Fix It:
Start by checking your workflow settings to make sure emails aren’t firing off at the same time.
For a smoother welcome experience, space out your emails by at least a day. If your goal is to keep readers engaged, pacing is important — 1–2 days between emails lets them absorb your content without feeling bombarded.
Pro Tip:
Review the timing of your workflows with fresh eyes. Try putting yourself in the subscriber’s shoes: Would you feel overwhelmed by the frequency, or does the pacing give enough breathing room to stay interested?
2. Forgetting Personalization
Automated doesn’t have to mean impersonal. Subscribers expect a personal touch, even if they know the emails are automated.
Using their name or speaking to their preferences can make each message feel like it was written just for them & give off the “quit reading my mind!” vibes.
How to Fix It:
Use segments and tags to track subscriber behaviors and personalize content based on actions they’ve already taken.
For instance, if a customer frequently browses specific products, consider highlighting similar items in your email. And while it’s easy to default to using their name, make sure the entire message reflects their interests.
Pro Tip:
Personalization goes beyond a name. Focus on the subscriber’s journey — what might they be thinking or feeling at this point?
Adjust the content to reflect their needs, and keep the focus on their experience rather than yours.
3. Not Setting Clear Goals for Each Workflow
Without a clear purpose, even the most well-designed workflows can fall flat. If subscribers don’t know why they’re receiving each email, it’s easy for them to lose interest.
How to Fix It:
Outline the big-picture goal for each workflow, then map out the purpose of each individual email.
For example, in a welcome series, the goal might be to introduce your brand, share helpful resources, and offer a special discount for new subscribers.
Each email should serve one of these objectives, to avoid confusing your readers.
Pro Tip:
Make each email intentional by creating a mini-goal for every step in the workflow.
Instead of “driving engagement,” be specific — like introducing a core product or addressing a common question. This helps keep the journey seamless and meaningful.
4. Letting Content Get Stale
Automations are convenient, but if they’re left untouched for too long, the content can feel outdated.
Old branding, irrelevant offers, or broken links can make your emails feel disconnected and miss the mark.
How to Fix It:
Review your workflows every 3-6 months to make sure everything still reflects your current goals and brand voice.
Update links, tweak copy if needed, and check that each email fits with your latest offers or any rebranding you’ve done. This way, your subscribers are always getting fresh, up-to-date content.
Pro Tip:
Set a reminder in your calendar to do an email check-in every few months. Just like a spring-cleaning for your inbox, a quick audit can keep your emails relevant and engaging.
Reminder: It’s Totally Normal to Make Workflow Mistakes
Everyone makes mistakes with email workflows, especially since automations run in the background.
It’s easy to overlook small details until they add up, so if you’re noticing issues, don’t stress.
Regular audits are a part of learning and growing with your audience.
The more you stay attuned to your readers’ needs and habits, the easier it will be to adjust your workflows in a way that feels natural and connected.
Staying on Top of Your Email Workflows
Conducting a regular email workflow audit can help prevent those little missteps that push readers away.
From pacing to personalization, each step keeps your emails aligned with what your audience actually wants to receive.
Relevant, intentional workflows get your readers excited to hear from you, familiar with your brand voice, and expecting to continue hearing from you.
Taking time to adjust subject lines, design elements, and segmentation keeps each email looking great, reading smoothly, and reaching the right people.
With these four steps, you’re ready to refresh your workflows, knowing that every email has a purpose and connects with your readers on a deeper level.
Not Something You Have The Time To Take On?
I get it, sometimes you need to call in an expert. If you you’re looking for that expert, heyy 🙂 As a total email nerd, these are the projects I absolutely ADORE taking on.
I’ll come in, geek out over all the incredible things you already have in place, find a couple areas where we can make things work even better, and then I’ll build you your very own email game plan custom-created for you based on your goals.
All in under 2-weeks with The Oasis Package. It’s an 100+ point Audit, 90-Day Email Strategy Roadmap, and 90-Day Content Calendar so you know exactly what to say in every email for the next quarter to keep your readers excited to hear (and buy) from you.
If you’re interested, you can book a call here!
